Upgrading West Coast line 'not an alternative to HS2' [Rail News]





Date: 18/04/2016

THE project to build HS2 had 'withstood fierce debate and cross-examination', former transport secretary Andrew Adonis has told the House of Lords. Lord Adonis, who now chairs the National Infrastructure Commission, was speaking during the second reading debate of the Hybrid Bill which authorises Phase 1 of the project, which was approved by the House of Commons earlier this month. He was transport secretary in 2008 when the HS2 project began to be planned. He conceded that challenges exist, but warned the Lords that the often-touted alternative, that of upgrading the West Coast Main Line, would not meet future demands for transport. He explained: 'Upgrading a busy main line railway is like conducting open heart surgery on a moving patient. Its hardly a compelling alternative to HS2 let alone a cheap one.


External links

Upgrading West Coast line 'not an alternative to HS2'

Rail News

THE project to build HS2 had 'withstood fierce debate and cross-examination', former transport secretary Andrew Adonis has told the House of Lords. L...

Related news items

Tags: x High Speed 2

DateItem
21/01/2020Grimshaw reveals revised designs for new Birmingham HS2 station [Architects Journal]
21/08/2019HS2: how far has work got, and why might it be scrapped? [The Guardian]
10/05/2017Hitachi unveils AT400 British Bullet Train concept [Railway Gazette]
20/01/2017Britain launches HS2 rolling stock procurement [IRJ]
19/11/2016How Toton Sidings became a huge railway hub - in Victorian days [Nottingham Post]
15/11/2016HS2: Ministers confirm North West and Yorkshire routes [BBC News]
05/11/2016New West Coast rail franchise to run HS2 services [BBC News]
07/07/2016HS2 may be diverted around Sheffield, says report [Rail News]
28/06/2016HS2 has unrealistic timetable, says National Audit Office [BBC News]
14/05/2016HS2 may not even reach Manchester as Department for Transport faces having project taken out of its control [Telegraph]
10/05/2016Disruption looms as HS2 starts station work early [Times]
09/05/2016Work starts on construction of HS2 colleges [Rail News]
21/03/2016Agreement on plans to look at three-hour Scotland to London rail link [BBC News]
15/03/2016HS2 denies claims that its trains are at risk of derailing at top speeds [Guardian]
12/03/2016HS2 at risk of derailing at top speeds, report finds [Telegraph]
02/12/2015Government 'not pursuing' HS1-HS2 rail link [Rail News]
24/09/2015HS2: George Osborne urges China to pitch for £11.8bn contracts [BBC News]
15/09/2015Euston station HS2 plans 'should be scrapped' [BBC News]
25/03/2015HS2: Government has no 'convincing case' for £50bn rail line [BBC News]
28/10/2014What is HS3?: proposed sub-Pennine rail line explained [Guardian]
24/10/2014HS2: Phase two report proposes new station for Crewe [BBC News]
22/10/2014Britain’s railway network Transport mode of choice [GlobalRailNews]
21/07/2014Birmingham named as new HS2 headquarters [BBC News]
29/04/2014MPs reject calls for HS2 rail plans to be halted [BBC News]
15/03/2014HS2 should be seen as the future backbone of Britain's railway [Guardian]
28/02/2014Birmingham HS2 Curzon station plans unveiled [BBC News]
10/02/2014HS2 Toton station could see the relocation of up to 600 jobs [BBC News]
11/11/2013TfGM backs Manchester tram-train proposals [Railway Gazette]
27/10/2013Railway line shut by Beeching 'can save us £36bn' [Mail]
06/10/2013The Borders Railway: a £350m ticket to nowhere? [Sunday Herald]
24/09/2013HS2: 12 arguments for and against [BBC News]
26/06/2013Treasury gives £12bn Crossrail 2 project funds to get started [Independent]
19/04/2013HS2 Euston station total rebuild plan scrapped [BBC]
15/03/2013HS2 ruling 'a victory' despite unlawful compensation move [BBC News]
28/01/2013HS2 announcement: 'a vital engine for growth' [Independent]
28/10/2012The rise of rail nostalgia [Telegraph]
29/09/2012HS2 rail line could be re-routed to Heathrow [Telegraph]
10/01/2012HS2: Phase one of high-speed rail line gets go-ahead [BBC News]
08/11/2011Scotland urged to begin work for high-speed rail link [BBC News]
27/02/2011Councils oppose high speed rail route [LocalGovUK]
07/11/2010National Trust anger over High Speed 2 [Telegraph]